What's New?

How to Check PCB Board Quality: 7 Testing Methods

How to Check PCB Board Quality: 7 Testing Methods

Ensuring the quality of Printed Circuit Boards (PCBs) is crucial for the reliability of electronic devices, ranging from smartphones to laptops and televisions. Testing the quality of PCBs involves several common methods: In-Circuit Testing (ICT), Flying Probe Testing, Automated Optical Inspection (AOI), Aging Tests, X-ray Inspection, Functional Testing, and other specialized tests. Each method has its unique advantages and applicable scenarios. Let's delve into each method and its significance.

In-Circuit Testing (ICT)

In-Circuit Testing (ICT) stands as the most reliable current PCB testing type. This real-time testing helps to immediately identify and correct errors, ensuring the quality of the final product. One of its major advantages is the ability to detect errors early, thus reducing the risk of defective boards entering late-stage production. Despite its high cost, typically tens of thousands of dollars, ICT is also known as bed-of-nails testing, focusing on initiating and examining individual circuits on the PCB. While ICT aims for 100% coverage in most cases, actual coverage usually falls between 85-90%. Unlike other methods, ICT’s main advantage lies in its coverage being unaffected by human error, thanks to a fixed probe layout matching the PCB design.

ICT tests the integrity of soldered connections using fixed probes that correspond to predefined access points on the PCB. Once the PCB is pushed onto the probe bed, the test starts automatically, with the probes applying appropriate pressure to ensure reliable connections. This method is particularly suitable for PCBs with complex connections or Ball Grid Arrays (BGAs), ideal for mature products expected to have high stability and few modifications.

However, it's important to note that if your PCB design lacks suitable access points for ICT testing, or if your production strategy isn't geared towards frequent design changes, ICT may not be the most suitable choice. Switching to an ICT strategy during production requires detailed planning and design beforehand.

Flying Probe Testing

Flying Probe Testing is a flexible and non-invasive method for testing PCB electrical performance. This method uses moving probes to contact test points on the PCB. Its flexibility makes it suitable for small batch production and prototypes since it doesn’t require custom test fixtures. Moreover, the probes can access almost any point on the PCB, ensuring comprehensive testing. However, compared to other methods, Flying Probe Testing is slower and has limited throughput, making it less suitable for large-scale production.

Automated Optical Inspection (AOI)

Automated Optical Inspection (AOI) is widely used in manufacturing environments for its faster and more accurate detection results compared to manual methods. AOI utilizes 3D or 2D cameras to take pictures of PCBs and compares them with detailed schematics. Engineers inspect PCBs marked as mismatched with the schematics. However, AOI is not a universal solution. It cannot test PCB electrical functionality and does not cover all PCB components. Therefore, it is best practice to combine AOI with other testing methods such as Flying Probe Testing or In-Circuit Testing to ensure comprehensive quality control. AOI is particularly useful after soldering PCBs. It helps to promptly identify issues like loose solder on the production line and take swift action to avoid adverse effects on subsequent PCB manufacturing.

Aging Tests

Aging tests are essential for assessing the long-term stability of PCBs. They simulate extreme conditions that PCBs would face in real-world usage to predict their performance over extended periods. These tests typically include aspects like high temperature, humidity, and electrical loads.

During aging tests, PCBs are typically placed in a constant temperature and humidity environment, with settings based on actual application requirements. During testing, the PCBs endure continuous electrical loads, simulating working conditions under high load. This not only detects PCB electrical stability but also identifies potential soldering issues, material aging, and other factors that could lead to failures.

This approach allows engineers to quickly identify potential issues that may arise during future use of PCBs, enabling timely adjustments to design or production processes to ensure the reliability and durability of the final product.

X-ray Inspection

X-ray inspection examines the internal structure of PCBs, particularly useful for detecting defects in solder joints and hidden connections. X-rays provide detailed views of the PCB's internal structure, revealing defects that traditional inspection methods cannot see. This is crucial for inspecting multilayer PCBs and complex components.

Functional Testing

Functional testing checks PCBs under actual working conditions to ensure they operate as expected. This method verifies if the PCB meets design specifications and functions correctly. The process involves connecting the PCB to the required power and load conditions, running the PCB through various operational scenarios to check its performance, and analyzing results to ensure normal operation under all test conditions.

Other Specialized Tests

Depending on specific PCB requirements, there are various other specialized testing methods. Environmental testing exposes PCBs to different environmental conditions like humidity, vibration, and thermal cycling to ensure durability. Signal integrity testing examines signal transmission quality to prevent issues in high-speed PCBs. Electromagnetic Compatibility (EMC) testing ensures that PCBs do not emit or receive electromagnetic interference that could affect their performance.


Testing PCB quality is a multifaceted process ensuring the reliability and performance of electronic devices. From in-line testing during manufacturing to X-ray inspection and specialized tests like environmental testing, each method plays a crucial role. By understanding and applying these testing methods, manufacturers can produce high-quality PCBs that meet stringent requirements for modern electronic devices. Remember, the goal is to detect potential issues early to ensure each PCB operates as expected in its intended environment. Whether you're manufacturing a simple calculator or a complex computer motherboard, using a combination of these testing methods will help you achieve optimal results.